An independent insurance agency built on trust, transparency, and a genuine commitment to protecting our clients.
American First Insurance Services LLC was founded with a single mission: to provide individuals, families, and businesses with the insurance coverage they truly need — not simply what's easiest to sell. As an independent agency, we are not tied to any single carrier, which means we can objectively shop the market on your behalf and find coverage that genuinely fits your life.
The insurance landscape can be confusing, and too many people end up over-paying for under-performing coverage. We exist to fix that. Our licensed professionals take the time to understand your situation before making any recommendations — and we continue to serve you long after the policy is issued.
Independence is our foundation. When you work with American First, you are working with an advocate. We represent you, not the insurance companies. When a claim needs to be filed, when a policy needs to be adjusted, when your circumstances change — we are on your side.
Our team holds active licenses across multiple lines of insurance and maintains relationships with more than 30 of the nation's most respected carriers. This breadth allows us to tailor solutions for virtually any coverage need, from a renter's first apartment to a multi-location commercial operation.
We believe that quality insurance coverage should be accessible, understandable, and priced fairly. That belief drives every conversation we have with every client we serve.
To be the first call our clients make when they face uncertainty — and the reason they sleep easier once we have spoken. American First Insurance Services LLC is built on the conviction that protection is not a product but a promise, and we intend to keep ours.
Get in TouchWe provide honest recommendations based solely on your best interests. We will never recommend coverage you do not need.
No jargon, no hidden fees, no surprises. We explain every policy in plain language so you know exactly what you are covered for.
Your security is our only priority. We build long-term relationships based on consistent, responsive service and genuine care.
Our licensed professionals stay current with the evolving insurance landscape to bring you the most informed guidance possible.
When you have a question or a claim, you deserve timely answers. We prioritize prompt, substantive communication.
We are proud to serve the families and businesses in our community and are committed to their long-term well-being.
Jonah Kalaty is the founding principal of American First Insurance Services LLC. With a background in client advisory and risk management, Jonah brings a disciplined, client-first approach to every policy conversation.
His philosophy is straightforward: insurance should be a tool for security, not a source of confusion. Jonah takes time with every client to ensure they understand their coverage, their options, and the reasoning behind every recommendation.
Jonah holds active licenses across multiple insurance lines and is committed to continuous professional development to remain at the forefront of the industry.